Mumbai, May 1: The Bombay High Court provided significant relief to comedian Bharti Singh and actor Shekhar Suman on Wednesday by ordering the dismissal of an FIR filed in 2010. During the hearing, the court clarified that comments made for the purpose of humor and satire are not intended to hurt the sentiments of any community.
The court noted that the words deemed objectionable included “Ya Allah! Rasgulla! Dahi Bhalla!” The petitioners argued that these terms were merely used for rhyme and humor. They contended that “Dahi Bhalla” and “Rasgulla” are common food items enjoyed by people from all communities, and there is no religious connotation in these expressions. This argument cannot be overlooked. In everyday social usage, these words are neutral. Mentioning food items in a comedic context cannot be deemed as an insult to religion. There must be evidence to prove that these words were chosen as weapons of insult.
The court also acknowledged that targeting artists has become easier due to their accessibility, but misusing criminal law is equally wrong. They further stated that the show was broadcast as a family entertainment program and had been running for a considerable time. The petitioners argued that the goal of artists and judges in such programs is to evoke laughter.
According to the court, the current circumstances appear relevant for resolving the case. A performing artist typically acts according to a predetermined script. The available evidence does not clearly indicate that the petitioning judges wrote those dialogues. Their role is so limited that the charges against them do not appear to be substantiated at first glance. The court cannot accept the prosecution’s broad argument that lacks a solid basis. When a complaint lacks essential facts and does not substantiate the crime, continuing criminal proceedings would be an abuse of judicial process.
The court ordered the cancellation and dismissal of the FIR registered at the Pydhonie police station on November 27, 2010, under Section 295-A of the Indian Penal Code along with Section 34, and all consequential proceedings arising from it.
–
P.S./A.S.
My name is Narendra Jijhontiya. I am an experienced content writer with several years of expertise in the field. Currently, I contribute to Daily Kiran, creating engaging and informative content across a variety of categories including TECHNOLOGY, health, travel, education, and automobiles. My goal is to deliver accurate, insightful, and captivating information through my words to help readers stay informed and empowered.
Leave a Comment