New Delhi, May 21: The political landscape in West Bengal has heated up over the mandatory singing of “Vande Mataram” in madrasas. Malik Motasim Khan, Vice President of Jamaat-e-Islami Hind, has openly shared his views on this contentious issue. He stated that loving one’s country and pressuring someone to sing a particular song are two distinct matters. He emphasized that while individuals are free to sing “Vande Mataram” if they wish, the government cannot impose this on any citizen.
In a recent conversation, Khan remarked that the Constitution of India grants every citizen the right to hold their own opinions and preferences. Respecting the nation is a duty for everyone, but the choice of which song to sing should remain personal. He pointed out that the courts have repeatedly clarified that no one can be forced to sing the national anthem or any song. If madrasas receive any advice on this matter, it should only be advisory, not a coercive order.
He stated, “Those who wish to sing can do so freely, and those who do not, should not be compelled.” According to him, democracy should allow individuals to make decisions based on their religious and cultural sentiments. He warned that any government coercion would be contrary to the spirit of the Supreme Court and the Constitution.
Recently, discussions have emerged regarding strict regulations from the government concerning animal sacrifice ahead of Bakrid in West Bengal. Khan addressed this by noting that Islam recognizes not only cows but also several other animals as halal for sacrifice. He mentioned, “Buffalo, goat, sheep, and many other animals can be sacrificed.”
He added that if the government bans cow sacrifice, Muslims have other options available. He urged Muslims not to insist solely on cow sacrifice and to approach the situation with peace and understanding.
Khan also raised questions about government policies, pointing out that large slaughterhouses operate in the country, exporting beef abroad. He claimed many of these businesses are run by non-Muslims, making it unjust to target only Muslims. If the government genuinely seeks to protect cows, it should first take action against these large slaughterhouses where extensive operations are conducted.
He highlighted that livestock farming and the cattle trade are significant parts of the rural economy. Sudden government restrictions could adversely affect the economic stability of villages. He stressed that this issue transcends religious boundaries and is also an economic concern.
Regarding the ongoing controversy about a minor from Bijnor, Uttar Pradesh, converting to Islam in Kashmir, Khan stated that the Constitution of India allows every individual the freedom to practice and change their religion. If someone chooses to embrace a faith of their own accord, it is their fundamental right. Everyone should have the freedom to choose their path, and others should not be disturbed by this decision. He affirmed, “Let everyone adopt what they find right; it is a personal choice.”
Khan concluded by stating that the beauty of democracy lies in the freedom for every citizen to think, speak, and live according to their own beliefs. He asserted that the government’s role is not to impose its preferences on people but to protect the rights of all.
–
Leave a Comment