Skip to content
Friday, 20 November 2026
BREAKING
Politics

Supreme Court Denies Immediate Hearing on Election Commissioner Appointment Case

The Supreme Court has rejected a request for an immediate hearing on the election commissioner appointment law case, emphasizing procedural adherence.

New Delhi, November 20 (Daily Kiran) : The Supreme Court of India declined to consider a request from lawyer Prashant Bhushan for an urgent hearing regarding a petition challenging the law on the appointment of election commissioners. Bhushan sought to have the matter listed before the same bench that previously referred it to a constitutional bench.

Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud informed Bhushan that objections to the reference order could be raised before the five-judge constitutional bench already established to hear the case.

Representing the petitioners, Bhushan argued for the immediate listing of the recall application before the bench that included Justices Deepankar Dutta and Satish Chandra Sharma, who had issued the reference order. He emphasized that Justice Sharma is set to retire next week and urged the Chief Justice to expedite the hearing.

However, Chief Justice Chandrachud dismissed this request, stating that the issue could be addressed when the case comes before the five-judge bench. He also indicated that the constitutional bench could still deliberate on the recall application, even after Justice Sharma’s retirement. The request to list the application before the original two-judge bench was also rejected.

The recall application seeks to revisit a September 23 order where Justices Dutta and Sharma disagreed on whether the constitutional validity of the “Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Tenure) Act, 2023” should be referred to a larger bench. Justice Dutta had dismissed the request to send the matter to a larger bench, while Justice Sharma believed it involved significant constitutional interpretation that warranted consideration by a constitutional bench.

Due to the differing opinions, the matter was escalated to the Chief Justice for appropriate orders, leading to the formation of a five-judge bench.

The recall application also questions Justice Sharma’s participation in the proceedings, citing a potential conflict of interest since his son has previously represented the Election Commission of India as a standing counsel.

These petitions challenge a 2023 law that removed the Chief Justice of India from the selection committee responsible for appointing the Chief Election Commissioner and other election commissioners, replacing him with a cabinet minister appointed by the Prime Minister. Petitioners argue that excluding the Chief Justice from the selection committee undermines the independence of the Election Commission, which is constitutionally mandated to ensure free and fair elections.

Share