Skip to content
Friday, 20 November 2026
BREAKING
INDIA

Delhi High Court Dismisses Doctors Petition to Remove Bail Order from Google Search Results

The Delhi High Court has rejected a doctors plea to remove a 2019 bail order from Google search results, directing the case to Guwahati High Court.

New Delhi, November 20 (Daily Kiran) : The Delhi High Court has dismissed a petition filed by a doctor seeking the removal of a 2019 bail order from online search results on Google and the legal database ‘Indian Law.’ The court ruled that merely residing in Delhi or the availability of online judicial records in the national capital does not grant jurisdiction to Delhi courts over this matter.

Justice Swarna Kanta Sharma stated that since the FIR, arrest, bail proceedings, and the eventual acquittal of the petitioner all took place in Assam, the appropriate venue for addressing the complaint is the Guwahati High Court.

The petitioner had approached the Delhi High Court, requesting directives to Google and ‘Indian Law’ to de-index the bail order issued by the Guwahati High Court on September 27, 2019, and to cease name-based searches for this judicial record. Despite being acquitted by a judicial magistrate in Assam on January 8, 2021, the petitioner argued that the bail order continues to appear in Google searches, adversely affecting their reputation and professional standing.

The petitioner contended that the acquittal order is now final, and under Article 21 of the Constitution, they are entitled to relief based on the right to informational privacy. However, the respondents raised preliminary objections, questioning the jurisdiction of the Delhi High Court and asserting that the entire criminal proceedings occurred in Assam, where the bail order was issued.

Justice Sharma accepted this objection, emphasizing that the petitioner’s residence in Delhi is not a significant factor in this case, and jurisdiction cannot be established solely on that basis. The court noted that the filing of the FIR, the issuance of the bail order by the Guwahati High Court, the submission of the charge sheet, and the subsequent acquittal all occurred in Assam, which are critical facts underpinning the claim.

The ruling stated, “The relevant judicial records belong to the Guwahati High Court. Additionally, the records of the original criminal proceedings are also located in Assam, which is essential for determining whether the petitioner is entitled to the relief sought.”

Rejecting the argument that the availability of the bail order through Google and ‘Indian Law’ in Delhi constitutes a part of the ’cause of action,’ Justice Sharma remarked that judicial records uploaded on the internet can be accessed nationwide and even globally.

The judge cautioned that if the mere availability of digital judicial records in one location were to be deemed a crucial part of the ’cause of action,’ every high court in the country could claim jurisdiction over requests to remove judicial records from the internet.

The Delhi High Court referenced the principle of ‘forum convenience,’ stating that the Guwahati High Court is the more appropriate forum for this dispute. This is because any directive regarding access to or searching for judicial records is best managed by that court.

The court further noted that hearing this petition could lead to conflicting or contradictory orders from two different high courts regarding the same judicial record.

In its conclusion, the Delhi High Court dismissed the petition and pending applications based on the lack of jurisdiction, allowing the petitioner to pursue other legal avenues, including approaching the Guwahati High Court. The court clarified that its comments should not be interpreted as an opinion on the merits of the doctor’s claim for ‘de-indexing.’

Share