Delhi High Court Accepts Restaurant Association Petitions but Denies Interim Relief on Service Charges
The Delhi High Court has accepted petitions from restaurant associations but denied interim relief regarding mandatory service charges.

New Delhi, November 19 (Daily Kiran) : The Delhi High Court has agreed to hear petitions from hotel and restaurant associations regarding the mandatory collection of service charges on bills. On Thursday, the court accepted appeals from the National Restaurant Association of India (NRAI) and the Federation of Hotel and Restaurant Associations of India (FHRAI). However, it made it clear that no interim relief has been granted to restaurant operators at this time.
The bench, consisting of Acting Chief Justice Nitin Vasudev Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma, stated during the hearing that whether to tip restaurant staff is entirely at the discretion of the customer. In India, it cannot be mandated, as there is no law supporting such a requirement.
During the proceedings, the court raised questions about why restaurants do not include service charges in the total bill and instead charge customers separately. A lawyer representing one of the appellants explained that restaurants keep service charges separate because they are meant for employee contributions.
In response, the bench questioned why hotels and restaurants do not incorporate all charges into the food bill. They provided an analogy, stating that if someone processes an item costing 100 rupees and sells it for 1,000 rupees, they are not asked why the additional 900 rupees are being charged, as that is considered processing fees.
The bench also noted that while some foreign restaurants require a certain percentage of the bill to be given as a tip, no such law exists in India.
During the hearing, Additional Solicitor General Chetan Sharma informed the court that despite a detailed ruling from a single judge clarifying that restaurants do not have the right to impose service charges, there have been thousands of complaints from consumers across the country. These complaints allege that some restaurants continue to charge service fees.
He pointed out that restaurant operators previously justified service charges by claiming the matter was pending in the High Court. Even after the acceptance of appeals, they might continue to collect service charges on the same grounds. The court reiterated that it has not provided any interim relief to restaurant operators.
Last year, a single judge of the High Court dismissed petitions from restaurant organizations challenging the 2022 guidelines issued by the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA). These guidelines prohibit hotels and restaurants from automatically including service charges in bills.
The single judge upheld the CCPA guidelines and dismissed the petitions from both restaurant organizations, imposing a fine of one lakh rupees on each petitioner to be deposited with the CCPA for consumer welfare.
The court clarified that mandatorily collecting service charges on food bills is against the law. However, it noted that customers are free to tip if they choose. This amount cannot be automatically included in the bill or invoice and should be left entirely to the customer’s discretion.
The single judge also remarked that the mandatory collection of service charges can be perceived as coercive, as customers might mistakenly believe it is a government-mandated tax or service fee. Collecting service charges by default, without providing customers a choice, cannot be deemed binding under contract law.
The court suggested that the CCPA consider rebranding service charges. It proposed terms like “tip,” “gratuity,” or “voluntary contribution” and recommended allowing names such as “voluntary contribution,” “staff contribution,” or “staff welfare fund.”



